Historical Success in the Stock Market
Historical success in the stock market is mostly based on two factors. Diversification and time in the market.
Diversification and Time in the Market
- Diversification – the simplest way to explain this is to not own enough of any one thing to make a killing in it, nor to get killed by it. Our ideal portfolios have more than 13,000 companies in them. If one or two or ten go totally bankrupt, you probably won’t even notice. But if you have only ten companies and one goes bankrupt, you notice and suffer the loss.
- Time in the market. According to Dimensional Funds Advisors, 94.7% of historical 10-year periods in the stock market were positive. 87.7% of historical 5-year periods were positive. And 75.2% of 1-year periods were positive.
Source: https://www.dimensional.com/us-en/insights/the-uncommon-average
A Real-Life Example: Walter’s Story
There is an example of a real client I had that I like to use. We’ll call him Walter. Walter wanted to hire me as his advisor but warned me that he likes to keep his money “safe” because he “can’t afford to lose it.”
After reviewing his current investments, I could see that all of his money was in relatively low return fixed annuities, bond mutual funds, and CDs.
First, we helped him determine how much of his money he was going to need each year. We discovered that the amount of money he needed annually was high compared to the total amount he had saved. He thought this was exactly why he needed to be “safe.”
Then we ran a Probability of Success calculation based on his current investment strategy and discovered a 0% probability of success. The total investment was simply too small, and the projected return was too low for the money to last his projected lifetime. The only way for his money to last his lifetime with his current investments would be to get “lucky” and die young before his money ran out.
We compared the Probability of Success to a more “aggressive” investment strategy that included the stock market. We found the more aggressive strategy provided an 82% probability of success that his money would last his lifetime.
He couldn’t understand how the “riskier” strategy provided a higher Probability of Success. The reason is quite simple. The stock market investments are projected to achieve greater growth that caused his investments to last longer than the low growth strategy. Since he still invested some of the money that he needed more conservatively, he reduced the chance that he would be forced to sell his stock market portion at low prices, creating the losses he feared.
What “Safe” Really Means
So, is the stock market safe? It depends on what you mean by “safe.”
I think the plan that gives you the highest probability of success is the “safest” plan.
A caring and competent advisor can help you create a plan customized to your needs and goals.